2 posters
Tiger porshe
BigEddie93- Tanker
- Posts : 17
Join date : 2018-12-11
Age : 31
Location : North Lincolnshire
- Post n°2
Re: Tiger porshe
I like the comedic approach to the above; though the game seems to function not too dissimilar to things like World of Tanks and War Thunder, in that it assumes the vehicles are functioning as intended, and does not take into account design flaws such as unreliability. If it did, the Panther would suffer transmission problems, the Tiger engine problems and most of the Russian vehicles spontaneous breakdowns.
These are the stats I came up with, though I've not yet made a nice looking card. Essentially very similar to the 'early' Tiger card, but with alterations. The same as above but minus the 'Engine Problems' and with a slightly higher points cost.
These are the stats I came up with, though I've not yet made a nice looking card. Essentially very similar to the 'early' Tiger card, but with alterations. The same as above but minus the 'Engine Problems' and with a slightly higher points cost.
PaulAlfredGroschupf- Tanker
- Posts : 43
Join date : 2019-01-23
- Post n°3
Re: Tiger porshe
just thought it would make the game interesting on the basis that the reliability of this tnk wa shocking
BigEddie93- Tanker
- Posts : 17
Join date : 2018-12-11
Age : 31
Location : North Lincolnshire
- Post n°4
Re: Tiger porshe
PaulAlfredGroschupf wrote:just thought it would make the game interesting on the basis that the reliability of this tnk wa shocking
Oh yeah, absolutely. Like I said, it's an amusing rule. I certainly think I might try it out. Having the tank for 35 points instead of 38 would be handy, as it drops the cost of two down to 70 from 76, meaning you could take a better third tank or better equipment.
However, if this rule is going to be applied to the Tiger P then it should, at least, be applied to the Ferdinand/Elefant/Sd.Kfz. 184 as well I think, since they were so closely related.
Conversely, although the VK45.01 (P) prototype did undoubtedly suffer from it's Porsche Type 101 powerplants being prone to spontaneous up-fuckery, the subsequent vehicles used different engines, replacing the two Type 101s for two Maybach HL120 TRM engines as used in some Pz. II, IV and STuG variants. The Sd.Kfz. 184 was renowned for catching fire whilst ascending inclines but this is, I believe, largely attributed to the electrical drive being overloaded. Since the games are usually played on flat boards I don't think this is relevant.
So the question then becomes are we representing the VK45.01 (P) OR are we representing Pz.Bfw.VI (P)? The prototype had the Type 101 engine and only 100mm of frontal armour, the command tank issued to sPzJgrAbt 653 had the Maybach and 200mm.
PaulAlfredGroschupf- Tanker
- Posts : 43
Join date : 2019-01-23
- Post n°5
Re: Tiger porshe
my photoshop will not work anymore but you can add rules to it because it is unnofficial